30 club pairs · 195 shared players
- Everton & Aston Villa 16
- Everton & Manchester United 11
- Everton & Leicester City 10
- Everton & Manchester City 9
- Everton & Chelsea 9
- Everton & Southampton 9
- Everton & Barcelona 8
- Everton & Tottenham 8
- Everton & Newcastle 8
- Everton & Fulham 8
- Everton & Lille 7
- Everton & Valencia 7
- Everton & Leeds 7
- Everton & Bournemouth 7
- Everton & Monaco 6
- Everton & Inter 5
- Everton & Ajax 5
- Everton & Crystal Palace 5
- Everton & St. Étienne 5
- Everton & Nottm Forest 5
- Everton & Fenerbahçe 4
- Everton & Sevilla 4
- Everton & Arsenal 4
- Everton & Napoli 4
- Everton & Roma 4
- Everton & Paris SG 4
- Everton & Fiorentina 4
- Everton & West Ham 4
- Everton & Wolves 4
- Everton & E. Frankfurt 4